by Charlie
I'm a B2B SaaS product manager, and I build my own products on the side. Back in June, I decided to embark on a new venture and start IdeaHub, a newsletter sharing growth strategies, marketing tactics, and product development tips for founders.
The stats
- Website traffic to date: 14.2K.
- Email subscribers: 2K+.
- Monthly revenue: $250.
- Monthly costs: $100.
What worked
Indie Hackers:
Each week, I tailor and post my articles here, including a link back to the original. Doing this can drive anywhere from 100-300 clicks when working well, and usually ~20 newsletter subscribers.
I was also featured in the Indie Hackers newsletter, which is sent out to nearly 75K readers. This was completely organic, and I was honored to be included! This one link brought ~250 visitors and 100 subscribers over three days.
In total, Indie Hackers has accounted for roughly 30% of all traffic and subscribers.
Dev.to:
Dev.to is more focused on technical writing. Each week, I tailored and posted my articles to fit the style of the site. What worked best was making use of tags.
There are a few tags (#watercooler and #discuss) that have dedicated slots on the homepage. So, instead of fighting through the crowd of posts, I just curated additional posts to fit into those tags. That brought me a lot more traffic. Most posts to those tags would bring in 20-30 subscribers each time.
Dev.to has contributed roughly 20% of all traffic and subscribers.
Collaborations:
I didn't have any audience to start with, so it was difficult to find people who wanted to collaborate with me. Plus, if you both only have small sites, neither gets much value from it.
But, as I grew the email list, my offer became far more valuable. I started reaching out to other sites to swap links. That has brought in ~100 new subscribers.
To anyone starting a newsletter, my advice is to hold off on collaborating with others until you have at least 1K subscribers.
Reddit:
I commented on people's posts who were looking for advice, trying to offer some help to them.
Then, if it made sense to do so, I included a link to my site. I also always tried to include another resource alongside mine, so people had a choice on whether to read mine or not. This has worked well! I've gotten very supportive feedback from people, with very little backlash from self-promotion rules.
I've also met a few friends on Reddit, and set up calls with them where we have shared our ideas and journeys.
Overall, Reddit has brought ~ 30% of all traffic and subscribers.
What didn't work
Hacker News, social media, and SEO were all misses for me. I didn't do any intentional SEO for this project, as I've mainly been focusing on posting on sites that already have high traffic.
I think this is a big reason I was able to grow faster than most.
Monetization
Currently, I receive ~$1 per new subscriber through recommending other related newsletters as part of the signup flow.
I also run email sponsorships at around $100 each, where I add a featured section to an email. I get leads from the existing subscriber base, and from Passionfroot, where I run the sponsorships. I currently get one slot booked a month.
Discuss this story.